In his guest commentary in the Peoria Independent March 18, 2009, Jack Harper (R-Surprise) wrote: "Together, we will restore our manufacturing base and compete with the rest of the world for jobs that produce goods. We will educate the next generation with a goal of have college-educated producers. We will streamline government to do the things for you that you could not do for yourself."

While I agree that these are noble goals, I have to point out that actions speak louder than words. I find it laughable that Mr. Harper thinks that by cutting education funding to K-12 programs so that our school districts have no choice but to increase class sizes, reduce books & supplies, and eliminate "extras" like music and arts programs that Arizona will produce more "college-educated producers."

And, let’s ask Mr. Harper which colleges those "producers" will attend – certainly not the universities in Arizona. Programs and teachers are being cut in an effort to keep those schools alive – but what about quality?

I do not think providing a high quality education system is a socialistic strategy. Very few families in Arizona can afford private schools, especially now that jobs are being lost and companies are closing down. Mr. Harper wants Arizona to compete to bring companies with good jobs here.

I must ask what company wants to move here when our education system is under attack by our State Legislature? What kind of employers does he intend to attract – those who rely on unskilled labor?

Our children are our future. Their taxes will pay for our social security (as long as it exists) and will pay for services to keep the State of Arizona running. Mr. Harper and his like-minded peers will put this state in a downward spiral that it will take a long time to recover from.

I am pleased that Gov. Brewer understands that there are some things that are worth paying more for – like our children. I am all for cutting out wasteful spending whether it is in our schools or in our state administration and programs. I think people do need to do things for themselves as much as possible. But when we, the current voting and tax paying generation, get older, it sure will be important to have doctors and medical services available, for example.

If our state services are cut, then we had better have decent jobs with benefits and retirement plans available to help support us when we are no longer able to work. Educating the young people who live in this state is the foundation of our future. Extremes are useful when you are in a debate. Compromise is necessary when you are living in the real world. Glad to hear your opinion, Mr. Harper. Sure hope you will listen to mine.

Suzanne Berger